(* * * This joint letter is initiated by Viet Tan * * *)
Mark Zuckerberg
Meta Platforms Inc
1 Hacker Way
Menlo Park, CA 94025
February 1, 2023
Dear Mark,
February 4th marks nearly two decades since Facebook was founded in 2004. On this 19th birthday, we urge you to recommit to giving people the power to build community and bringing the world closer together.
Facebook has revolutionized how we consume, create, and share information. But it has also increasingly become a tool to suppress the very freedom of expression it was meant to promote, as political actors have manipulated the platform to curtail dissent and harass opponents.
Vietnam has been a prime example:
- Sophisticated networks of seemingly authentic Facebook accounts mass report activist accounts to take down content and use bots to proliferate false information.
In July and December 2021, Reuters reported that Facebook removed networks of accounts that targeted Vietnamese activists critical of the country’s government.1 One particular group was called “E47,” which has military and non-military members coordinating ways to mass report and spam accounts. This group is connected to Force 47, the Vietnamese military’s cyber unit that is charged with defending party ideology online since 2016.
Despite Facebook’s apparent removal of the E47 group, Reuters still found tens of thousands of users connected to other known Force 47 groups. Additionally, attacks continue to persist. In October 2022, dozens of activists and prominent Facebook pages were targeted by bots spamming messages relentlessly for several weeks.2 Since a key Facebook metric is focused on highlighting posts that get a large number of comments, such spamming tactics allow the content of these attacks to spread further, misinform, and harm online social interactions.3
- Harmful networks in Vietnam reveal a concern regarding account authenticity — an issue directly affecting investors, advertisers, and human rights defenders.
Internal Facebook documents publicized by whistleblower Frances Haugen mention the existence of potentially 15 million fake accounts in Vietnam. Not only do these fake accounts skew the accuracy of the supposed 70 million Facebook users in Vietnam, but they also contribute to the mass reporting of authentic accounts.
Furthermore, the farming of clicks to cultivate a real audience base for Facebook pages and groups creates inauthentic social interactions. This tactic entails hiring people to click on links to increase the virality of a post, or constantly publishing content that misleads and exaggerates to attract actual users. Vietnam is apparently at the center of a booming fake account industry that’s scaled up by mass automation. The motive may be for monetary or political gains, but the result is the spread of misinformation.4
Facebook previously announced how authentic users can coordinate social harm through the case of the Querdenken movement in Germany, and the team immediately removed the network’s accounts, pages, and groups.5
In the year ahead, we call on you to fully address ongoing coordinated social harm on the Facebook platform, especially in Vietnam. Specifically, we urge you to:
1) Delete the millions of reportedly fake Facebook accounts in Vietnam and consider policy changes to disincentivize flagrant “click-bait” behavior.
2) Shut down networks that engage in coordinated mass reporting and other social harms.
3) Provide an avenue for Vietnamese activists, journalists and stakeholders to appeal content takedowns and to work directly with Facebook staff when targeted by coordinated social harm campaigns.
As you expand into tomorrow’s metaverse, we hope that you will commit to ensuring safe and authentic interactions on your platforms today.
Sincerely,
Brotherhood for Democracy (Hội Anh Em Dân Chủ) | fb.com/hoianhemdanchu
Cambodian Journalists Alliance Association | fb.com/CambodianJournalistsAllianceCatholic Youth (Thanh Niên Công Giáo) | fb.com/thanhnienconggiao
Destination Justice | fb.com/DestinationJustice
Free Journalists Club of Vietnam (Câu Lạc Bộ Nhà Báo Tự Do) | fb.com/caulacbonhabaotudo
Horizontal#MilkTeaAlliance
Calendar Team#MilkTeaAlliance
Friends of MyanmarMyanmar Internet ProjectNew Horizon Media (Chân Trời Mới Media) | fb.com/chantroimoimedia
PEN America | fb.com/PENamerica
Reporters Without Borders | fb.com/Reporterssansfrontieres
Safeguard Defenders
Saigon Broadcasting Television Network | fb.com/SBTNOfficial
V5TV Tin Tức Úc Việt | fb.com/profile.php?id=100063708034647
Viet Tan | fb.com/viettan
Các nhà hoạt động & các dân báo, bloggers:
Anh Chi | fb.com/profile.php?id=100026717114516
Bui Hue | fb.com/jerry.bui.79069
Philip Bui | fb.com/bui.v.phu
Son Bui | fb.com/TheSonBui
Dao Ba Ke | fb.com/profile.php?id=100004537337205
Dang Huu Nam | fb.com/lm.anton.danghuunam
Dang Thi Hue | fb.com/danghuevt
Doan Thi Thuy Duong | fb.com/profile.php?id=100004905254586
Do Le Na | fb.com/huong.tudinh.967
Do Thi Thu | fb.com/profile.php?id=100008236984260
Suzie Dong Xuyen | fb.com/profile.php?id=100011455206810
Ho Duc Hoa | fb.com/profile.php?id=100081058157991
Hoang Tu Duy | fb.com/hoangtuduy71
Huynh Ngoc Chenh | fb.com/ho.lytien.1
Huynh Van Ba | fb.com/profile.php?id=100003673032911
Paulus Le Son | fb.com/son.vanle85
Le Thanh Tung | fb.com/anthonylethanhtung
Le Thi Thap | fb.com/comuoi.hole.78
Manh Kim | fb.com/nguyen.manhkim
Nguyen Dinh Ha | fb.com/senator.nguyen
JB Nguyen Huu Vinh | fb.com/jbnguyenhuuvinh
Nguyen Manh Hung | fb.com/tamlinh.tran.188
Nguyen Thi Anh Tuyet | fb.com/tuyet.ohlala
Nguyen Thi Chau | fb.com/chau.nguyenthi.7771
Nguyen Thi Kim Chi | fb.com/chi.k.nguyen.94
Nguyen Thi Hue | fb.com/nguyen.hue.1610
Trang Nguyen | fb.com/tienlen.01.02.1990
Nguyen Van Hai | fb.com/dieucayclbnbtdvietnam
Nguyen Van Khanh | fb.com/profile.php?id=100001766666529
Dominic Pham | fb.com/dominic.pham.12
Moc Lan Pham | fb.com/lanpt.aus
Pham Minh Hoang | fb.com/phamminh.hoang.351
Than Pham | fb.com/maclam.pham
Pham Thanh Tam | fb.com/profile.php?id=100086496352356
Phong Van Phan | fb.com/luongdan.ly
Michel Tran Duc | fb.com/michel.tranduc
Tran Thi Thu Thuy | fb.com/tranthithuthuy83
Tran Minh Nhat | fb.com/minhnhat.paultran
Trinh Thi Nhung | fb.com/medadanntoc.duma
Trinh Thi Thao | fb.com/trinhthithao86
Truc Ho | fb.com/nhacsitrucho
Benny Truong | fb.com/profile.php?id=100005569474118
Tuan Khanh | fb.com/khanhtuanng
Tuong Thang | fb.com/tuong.thang
Elodie Vialle | fb.com/elodie.vialle
Vo Hong Ly | fb.com/hongly.vo.5059
Vo An Don | fb.com/bauquay
Vu Duc Khanh | fb.com/freedom.king.902266
Vu Thach | fb.com/thach.vu.980#StopVNtrolls
Reference
1. James Pearson, “How Vietnam’s ‘influencer’ army wages information warfare on Facebook,” Reuters, July 8, 2021, https://www.reuters.com/world/asia-pacific/how-vietnams-influencer-army-wages-information-warfare-facebook-2021-07-09/; James Pearson, “Facebook says it removes accounts which targeted Vietnamese activists,” Reuters, December 1, 2021, https://www.reuters.com/technology/facebook-says-it-removes-accounts-which-targeted-vietnamese-activists-2021-12-01/
2. “Harmful network targets Vietnamese civil society: Facebook must take action,” Viet Tan, October 28, 2022, https://viettan.org/en/harmful-network-targets-vietnamese-civil-society-facebook-must-take-action/amp/
3. Elizabeth Dwoskin, Tory Newmyer, and Shibani Mahtani, “The case against Mark Zuckerberg: Insiders say Facebook’s CEO chose growth over safety,” Washington Post, October 25, 2021, https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2021/10/25/mark-zuckerberg-facebook-whistleblower/
4. Elise Thomas, “Case Study 1: Farming Facebook,” ISD, Conspiracy Clickbait series, January 19, 2022, https://www.isdglobal.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/Conspiracy-Clickbait-Study-1.pdf
5. Nathaniel Gleicher, “Removing New Types of Harmful Networks,” Meta, September 16, 2021, https://about.fb.com/news/2021/09/removing-new-types-of-harmful-networks/
Height Insoles: Hi, I do believe this is an excellent site. I stumbledupon …
http://fishinglovers.net: Appreciate you sharing, great post.Thanks Again. Keep writi…
Achilles Pain causes: Every weekend i used to pay a quick visit this site, as i w…
February 3, 2023
Joint letter calling on Facebook to “unfriend” harmful social networks in Vietnam
by Defend the Defenders • [Human Rights]
(* * * This joint letter is initiated by Viet Tan * * *)
Mark Zuckerberg
Meta Platforms Inc
1 Hacker Way
Menlo Park, CA 94025
February 1, 2023
Dear Mark,
February 4th marks nearly two decades since Facebook was founded in 2004. On this 19th birthday, we urge you to recommit to giving people the power to build community and bringing the world closer together.
Facebook has revolutionized how we consume, create, and share information. But it has also increasingly become a tool to suppress the very freedom of expression it was meant to promote, as political actors have manipulated the platform to curtail dissent and harass opponents.
Vietnam has been a prime example:
In July and December 2021, Reuters reported that Facebook removed networks of accounts that targeted Vietnamese activists critical of the country’s government.1 One particular group was called “E47,” which has military and non-military members coordinating ways to mass report and spam accounts. This group is connected to Force 47, the Vietnamese military’s cyber unit that is charged with defending party ideology online since 2016.
Despite Facebook’s apparent removal of the E47 group, Reuters still found tens of thousands of users connected to other known Force 47 groups. Additionally, attacks continue to persist. In October 2022, dozens of activists and prominent Facebook pages were targeted by bots spamming messages relentlessly for several weeks.2 Since a key Facebook metric is focused on highlighting posts that get a large number of comments, such spamming tactics allow the content of these attacks to spread further, misinform, and harm online social interactions.3
Internal Facebook documents publicized by whistleblower Frances Haugen mention the existence of potentially 15 million fake accounts in Vietnam. Not only do these fake accounts skew the accuracy of the supposed 70 million Facebook users in Vietnam, but they also contribute to the mass reporting of authentic accounts.
Furthermore, the farming of clicks to cultivate a real audience base for Facebook pages and groups creates inauthentic social interactions. This tactic entails hiring people to click on links to increase the virality of a post, or constantly publishing content that misleads and exaggerates to attract actual users. Vietnam is apparently at the center of a booming fake account industry that’s scaled up by mass automation. The motive may be for monetary or political gains, but the result is the spread of misinformation.4
Facebook previously announced how authentic users can coordinate social harm through the case of the Querdenken movement in Germany, and the team immediately removed the network’s accounts, pages, and groups.5
In the year ahead, we call on you to fully address ongoing coordinated social harm on the Facebook platform, especially in Vietnam. Specifically, we urge you to:
1) Delete the millions of reportedly fake Facebook accounts in Vietnam and consider policy changes to disincentivize flagrant “click-bait” behavior.
2) Shut down networks that engage in coordinated mass reporting and other social harms.
3) Provide an avenue for Vietnamese activists, journalists and stakeholders to appeal content takedowns and to work directly with Facebook staff when targeted by coordinated social harm campaigns.
As you expand into tomorrow’s metaverse, we hope that you will commit to ensuring safe and authentic interactions on your platforms today.
Sincerely,
Brotherhood for Democracy (Hội Anh Em Dân Chủ) | fb.com/hoianhemdanchu
Cambodian Journalists Alliance Association | fb.com/CambodianJournalistsAllianceCatholic Youth (Thanh Niên Công Giáo) | fb.com/thanhnienconggiao
Destination Justice | fb.com/DestinationJustice
Free Journalists Club of Vietnam (Câu Lạc Bộ Nhà Báo Tự Do) | fb.com/caulacbonhabaotudo
Horizontal#MilkTeaAlliance
Calendar Team#MilkTeaAlliance
Friends of MyanmarMyanmar Internet ProjectNew Horizon Media (Chân Trời Mới Media) | fb.com/chantroimoimedia
PEN America | fb.com/PENamerica
Reporters Without Borders | fb.com/Reporterssansfrontieres
Safeguard Defenders
Saigon Broadcasting Television Network | fb.com/SBTNOfficial
V5TV Tin Tức Úc Việt | fb.com/profile.php?id=100063708034647
Viet Tan | fb.com/viettan
Các nhà hoạt động & các dân báo, bloggers:
Anh Chi | fb.com/profile.php?id=100026717114516
Bui Hue | fb.com/jerry.bui.79069
Philip Bui | fb.com/bui.v.phu
Son Bui | fb.com/TheSonBui
Dao Ba Ke | fb.com/profile.php?id=100004537337205
Dang Huu Nam | fb.com/lm.anton.danghuunam
Dang Thi Hue | fb.com/danghuevt
Doan Thi Thuy Duong | fb.com/profile.php?id=100004905254586
Do Le Na | fb.com/huong.tudinh.967
Do Thi Thu | fb.com/profile.php?id=100008236984260
Suzie Dong Xuyen | fb.com/profile.php?id=100011455206810
Ho Duc Hoa | fb.com/profile.php?id=100081058157991
Hoang Tu Duy | fb.com/hoangtuduy71
Huynh Ngoc Chenh | fb.com/ho.lytien.1
Huynh Van Ba | fb.com/profile.php?id=100003673032911
Paulus Le Son | fb.com/son.vanle85
Le Thanh Tung | fb.com/anthonylethanhtung
Le Thi Thap | fb.com/comuoi.hole.78
Manh Kim | fb.com/nguyen.manhkim
Nguyen Dinh Ha | fb.com/senator.nguyen
JB Nguyen Huu Vinh | fb.com/jbnguyenhuuvinh
Nguyen Manh Hung | fb.com/tamlinh.tran.188
Nguyen Thi Anh Tuyet | fb.com/tuyet.ohlala
Nguyen Thi Chau | fb.com/chau.nguyenthi.7771
Nguyen Thi Kim Chi | fb.com/chi.k.nguyen.94
Nguyen Thi Hue | fb.com/nguyen.hue.1610
Trang Nguyen | fb.com/tienlen.01.02.1990
Nguyen Van Hai | fb.com/dieucayclbnbtdvietnam
Nguyen Van Khanh | fb.com/profile.php?id=100001766666529
Dominic Pham | fb.com/dominic.pham.12
Moc Lan Pham | fb.com/lanpt.aus
Pham Minh Hoang | fb.com/phamminh.hoang.351
Than Pham | fb.com/maclam.pham
Pham Thanh Tam | fb.com/profile.php?id=100086496352356
Phong Van Phan | fb.com/luongdan.ly
Michel Tran Duc | fb.com/michel.tranduc
Tran Thi Thu Thuy | fb.com/tranthithuthuy83
Tran Minh Nhat | fb.com/minhnhat.paultran
Trinh Thi Nhung | fb.com/medadanntoc.duma
Trinh Thi Thao | fb.com/trinhthithao86
Truc Ho | fb.com/nhacsitrucho
Benny Truong | fb.com/profile.php?id=100005569474118
Tuan Khanh | fb.com/khanhtuanng
Tuong Thang | fb.com/tuong.thang
Elodie Vialle | fb.com/elodie.vialle
Vo Hong Ly | fb.com/hongly.vo.5059
Vo An Don | fb.com/bauquay
Vu Duc Khanh | fb.com/freedom.king.902266
Vu Thach | fb.com/thach.vu.980#StopVNtrolls
Reference
1. James Pearson, “How Vietnam’s ‘influencer’ army wages information warfare on Facebook,” Reuters, July 8, 2021, https://www.reuters.com/world/asia-pacific/how-vietnams-influencer-army-wages-information-warfare-facebook-2021-07-09/; James Pearson, “Facebook says it removes accounts which targeted Vietnamese activists,” Reuters, December 1, 2021, https://www.reuters.com/technology/facebook-says-it-removes-accounts-which-targeted-vietnamese-activists-2021-12-01/
2. “Harmful network targets Vietnamese civil society: Facebook must take action,” Viet Tan, October 28, 2022, https://viettan.org/en/harmful-network-targets-vietnamese-civil-society-facebook-must-take-action/amp/
3. Elizabeth Dwoskin, Tory Newmyer, and Shibani Mahtani, “The case against Mark Zuckerberg: Insiders say Facebook’s CEO chose growth over safety,” Washington Post, October 25, 2021, https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2021/10/25/mark-zuckerberg-facebook-whistleblower/
4. Elise Thomas, “Case Study 1: Farming Facebook,” ISD, Conspiracy Clickbait series, January 19, 2022, https://www.isdglobal.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/Conspiracy-Clickbait-Study-1.pdf
5. Nathaniel Gleicher, “Removing New Types of Harmful Networks,” Meta, September 16, 2021, https://about.fb.com/news/2021/09/removing-new-types-of-harmful-networks/